Skip to Content

The Best Homemade Poptarts

Poptarts are a childhood classic for me but, I was never really all that adventurous when it came to the various flavors. Simple strawberry with or without frosting was and still is my all-time favorite.

A few days ago while visiting my parents I came across a box of strawberry Poptarts. My immediate reaction was to toast one but after that impulse passed, I thought it would be fun to try and recreate that treat myself.

What kind of pie crust should you use?

You have two options here, make your own or buy your favorite refrigerated crust. I personally went with the latter as I have yet to perfect my own crust but I am working on it.

Once you have your crust, square it off and cut evenly to divide it into sections. You can use any straight edge to get this desired effect.

Pie Crust

Make an egg wash, for mine I used 1 egg and about 2 teaspoons of milk. Using a brush coat both the top and bottom of the tarts.

Why not just coat the edges?

Well, the egg wash not only provides the glue for the edges but also helps the jam stick to the inside of the tarts if applied there.

Pie Crust with egg wash
Pie Crusts with egg wash

Place about 1 tablespoon or a little more of jam on the bottom potion of the crust. Spread it out from the middle but be mindful of how close you are to the edges. You will want to leave a little space for sealing later.

Strawberry Jam on Pie Crust

Fold over the top of the crust and use a fork to seal all of the edges of the tarts.

Sealing Poptart Edges with fork
Sealed Poptart Edges

Create some holes on the top crust, I used a toothpick. I did a row of 4, then a row of 3 and repeated until the end.

Why the holes?

This small feature gives the steam a nice release pocket but also adds that classic Poptart feeling.

Holes in Poptart Crust Top

Time to chill

Once your poptarts are fully formed, place them in the refrigerator for 30 minutes and allow them to chill. They have been sitting at room temperature and the crust starts to get pretty pliable.

Giving them a chance to gain some firmness before popping them in the air fryer makes them easier to handle and less of a mess.

Frosting (Optional)

Combine the confectioners’ sugar, heavy cream, vanilla extract, and lemon juice together and set aside for later.

As a base, I started with 2 tablespoons of confectioners’ sugar and 1 teaspoon of extract. The heavy cream was used to create the consistency I wanted for the frosting. The lemon juice was added to taste for a nice way of balancing out all of the sweetness.

After your 30 minutes are up

Grab your tarts from the frig and place them in the air fryer at 350F for 10 minutes. The time may vary slightly depending on the model of your air fryer so give them a look around the 8-minute mark.

Once they reach a nice golden brown, remove them, add frosting if you opted for it, and let them cool before digging in.

Frosted Poptart out of Air Fryer

These turned out so well and the taste was comparable to my childhood classic. A breakfast or late-night snack that I will defiantly revisit when that old sweet tooth hits.

Poptarts

Poptarts

Yield: 4
Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 10 minutes
Additional Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour

The Best Homemade Poptarts cooked to perfection in the Air fryer.

Ingredients

  • Pie Crust
  • Strawberry Jam (any jam of your choice)
  • Egg
  • Milk
  • Butter Cooking Spray

Frosting (Optional)

  • Confectioners Sugar
  • Vanilla Extract
  • Lemon Juice
  • Heavy Cream

Instructions

  1. Roll out pie crust and cut edges to create a nice squared section
  2. Cut vertically to create even sections
  3. Make an egg wash by combining an egg and 2 teaspoons of milk
  4. Brush entire bottom and top of the crust with egg wash
  5. Add strawberry jam to each
  6. Fold over the top of the crust and seal using a fork around the edges
  7. Use a toothpick to create some holes on top of the crust
  8. Place in refrigerator to chill for 30 minutes
  9. Spray the airfryer and the poptarts with cooking spray
  10. Place poptarts in air fryer and cook at 350F for 10 minutes

Frosting (Optional)

  1. Combine confectioners sugar, vanilla extract, heavy cream, and lemon juice

    Notes

    For frosting start with 2 tablespoons of confectioners sugar and 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract. The heavy cream and lemon juice are to taste and desired consistency.

    Nutrition Information:
    Yield: 4 Serving Size: 1
    Amount Per Serving: Calories: 430Total Fat: 19gSaturated Fat: 8gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 9gCholesterol: 67mgSodium: 257mgCarbohydrates: 59gFiber: 1gSugar: 34gProtein: 6g

    Did you make this recipe?

    Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

    Previous
    How to Pack Your Life in a Carry-on
    Next
    Flakey Sourdough Biscuits
    Comments are closed.